Why every vote and every process matters

Democracy Is More Than Numbers

The recent local elections in Papatoetoe-Ōtara have generated discussions that go beyond simply identifying winners and losers. While some assert that alleged irregular votes are insignificant and would not affect the final outcome, such statements risk trivialising the underlying principles of democracy. Democracy is not solely about the result; it is built on trust, fairness, and transparency. Even a few irregular votes can prompt serious concerns. Accepting irregularities on the basis that they "don’t matter" can create a dangerous precedent, raising questions about where we draw the line if dishonesty is tolerated.

Integrity Builds Trust

The allegations involving the Papatoetoe-Ōtara Action Team (POAT) exemplify the importance of electoral integrity. Complaints have referenced mishandled special votes and anomalies in the ballots, with suggestions that community venues such as temples and gurdwaras may have played a role in improperly influencing voters. Although no legal verdicts have been reached, these concerns emphasise the need for vigilance. It is essential for communities to ensure that local elections are fair and not merely a reflection of established power networks.

Local body tickets like POAT operated independently of national parties, despite speculation online. Their notable victory demonstrates the influence of community networks in local politics and underscores the necessity for transparency. Members of the Indian community in New Zealand have a responsibility to participate thoughtfully, champion accountability, and take actions that build—rather than diminish—public trust.

Also Read: Why The Alleged Vote-Stealing In Papatoetoe Threatens The Mana Of Kiwi Indians

The Stakes Are Local

Local elections have a direct impact on services, infrastructure, and policies affecting daily life, including public transport, libraries, parks, and social programmes. If the electoral process is perceived as compromised, public confidence will falter, resulting in decreased participation. For communities that have traditionally been underrepresented, maintaining integrity is especially important. Every citizen should trust that their vote is counted fairly and accurately.

Vigilance Without Prejudice

Respecting due process is equally critical. Current police investigations and judicial petitions are underway to examine reported irregularities. Allegations must be addressed through legal procedures rather than speculation or assumptions. Balancing vigilance with fairness allows the community to seek accountability without unjustly undermining individuals before all facts are established.

A Call to Our Community

For Kiwi-Indians, engagement in local governance is essential. Participating in campaigns lawfully, promoting voter education, and advocating for transparency and accountability are vital. These efforts reinforce the mana of the community and show that involvement strengthens, rather than exploits, democracy. Upholding high standards benefits not just the present election but also the long-term credibility of our institutions. Accepting minor irregularities risks a slippery slope. Upholding integrity in local elections preserves public confidence, empowers voters, and protects the voice of every resident.

Beyond Papatoetoe

Papatoetoe-Ōtara serves as a case study, illustrating a principle that applies everywhere: democracy relies on proper process as much as outcome. Each vote must be safeguarded, every participant held to common standards, and all processes made transparent. Adhering to these principles ensures that communities remain vibrant, fairly represented, and respected.

Protecting Our Voice

Members of the Indian community have both the right and the duty to engage, to ask questions, and to model exemplary civic behaviour. By advocating for integrity, transparency, and accountability, we make certain that our voice counts and that our community’s mana endures for future generations. It is also essential that we challenge any behaviour within our own ranks that undermines election integrity. The community should openly denounce any attempts to manipulate the system. Ignoring such actions harms public trust and damages our collective reputation, as well as the progress we have achieved. These issues affect the entire community, not just those directly involved.

When we uphold the highest standards and refuse to tolerate misconduct, we set a positive example and help maintain the credibility of our participation in local governance. By confronting wrongdoing, we demonstrate that our engagement is focused on strengthening democracy for all, not exploiting it for temporary advantage.

Ilango Krishnamoorthy is a business owner based in Manukau and is associated with the New Zealand Labour Party. In the 2022 local elections, he stood as a Labour candidate for the Manurewa–Papakura Ward (Auckland Council) and the Manurewa Local Board, but was not elected.