Home /  News /  New Zealand

Court finds NZ pay reforms breached women's rights

NZ pay equity reforms breached rights of underpaid women
Brooke van Velden

New Zealand’s High Court has ruled that the coalition Government’s 2025 changes to the pay equity system breached the Bill of Rights Act by unjustifiably limiting the rights of underpaid women.

New call-to-action

According to a Stuff report, Justice Paul Radich delivered the judgment on Thursday. He found that the amendments to the Equal Pay Act were inconsistent with the right to freedom from discrimination on the grounds of sex.

The ruling will require Parliament and the next Government to reconsider the controversial changes, although it does not legally compel them to amend the legislation.

New call-to-action

The Government introduced the changes urgently ahead of the 2025 Budget, without prior public announcement. The amendments restricted the ability of workers in female-dominated professions to pursue pay equity claims and cancelled 33 existing claims involving workforces that argued they were being underpaid because of gender-based discrimination, as reported by Stuff.

Unions representing the affected workers said more than 150,000 women lost their claims following the changes.

Documents presented to the court revealed that concerns about the financial implications of pay equity claims had first been raised in December 2023. Finance Minister Nicola Willis was advised that teachers and care and support workers were expected to account for 80% of the projected costs because of the size of their workforces and the extent of their underpayment, Stuff has reported.

The Government finalised the legislative changes within two days of announcing its plans. The reforms were estimated to save $12.8 billion in potential wage increases over the following four years. Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden led the changes.

Initially, ministers and government officials defended the amendments as an effort to “improve” the pay equity system and make it “more robust” and fairer, as reported by Stuff.

However, after examining official records and hearing evidence from witnesses, Justice Radich found no evidence that the reforms had achieved those objectives.

“The reason for the ‘reset’ was strictly financial,” he said.

The court hearing also involved the cross-examination of Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment chief executive Nic Blakeley, who acknowledged repeating ministers' statements that the changes would improve the system's robustness, despite that not being his personal understanding of the reforms' objective.

Radich concluded that the previous system had been operating as intended and that the 2025 amendments had breached the Bill of Rights Act.

“The undervaluation of jobs dominated by female employees is discrimination,” he said, Stuff has quoted.

The judgement included a formal declaration of inconsistency, triggering parliamentary scrutiny and requiring a response from the next Attorney-General.

Explaining the significance of the declaration, Radich said:

“In this case, a declaration recognises the rights of the women the applicants represent; women who work within undervalued female-dominated workforces. They have ... been the subject of unjustified discrimination based on their sex. A declaration vindicates their positions. They deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, recognised by the Court,” Radich said in the judgment, as quoted by Stuff.

During the proceedings, former Solicitor-General Una Jagose KC defended the Government's position, arguing that the amended Equal Pay Act continued to provide avenues for women and female-dominated professions to pursue pay equity claims.

She maintained that the amendments could not themselves amount to sex-based discrimination because the legislation was intended to address existing inequalities rather than create them. She also argued there was no legal “positive obligation” requiring the Government to introduce legislation to address inequality, Stuff has reported.

Fleur Fitzsimons, national secretary of the Public Service Association (PSA), one of the unions that initiated the legal challenge in 2025, said the ruling increased pressure on the next Government to reverse the changes.

“The Court is right. The Government cynically cancelled pay equity claims under the cover of darkness, without warning and without due democratic process. And all to make the Budget windfall for landlords add up.

“Today the court has confirmed what women knew all along, pay equity is a fundamental right and must be upheld,” she said, as quoted by Stuff.

Justice Radich also ordered the Crown to pay the legal costs associated with the hearing.

Coalition Government responds

Van Velden, who retired from politics following the election but continued serving as Workplace Relations Minister in a caretaker capacity, said officials would examine the judgement. She also indicated that the Government could consider appealing the decision to the Court of Appeal.

“Crown needs to consider whether to appeal, so that limits what I or any Government minister can say,” she said, as quoted by Stuff.

She maintained that she wanted the pay equity system to continue, but believed the previous arrangements were not working effectively.

Van Velden also pointed out that the Government had received advice on whether the proposed legislation was consistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

Outgoing Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith, who was acting Attorney-General in May 2025, had personally approved that advice before the legislation was passed.

At the time, he concluded: “The bill appears to be consistent with the Bill of Rights Act”, as quoted by Stuff.

Stuff sought a response from Goldsmith following the High Court's decision, given his earlier advice to Cabinet that the legislation did not breach the Bill of Rights Act. However, he had not responded by the time of publication.

New Zealand’s High Court has ruled that the coalition Government’s 2025 changes to the pay equity system breached the Bill of Rights Act by unjustifiably limiting the rights of underpaid women.

{% module_block module "widget_b219cf58-7b00-49e7-8aee-822c4dcbe196" %}{% module_attribute "ads"...

Leave a Comment

Related Posts