More than 30 Indian migrant workers in New Zealand have accused an unlicensed immigration adviser of submitting false or misleading documents to Immigration New Zealand (INZ) without their knowledge, leaving many facing visa refusals and the risk of unlawful immigration status.
According to a report by Stuff, the allegations are directed at Sukhdeep Kaur Gill, a South Auckland woman who is accused of filing fraudulent documents on behalf of migrants seeking visa extensions. Gill has strongly denied all allegations, including claims that she met or provided immigration assistance to the affected workers.
One of the alleged victims, Balraj Singh, says he has never travelled to Canada. However, documents submitted to INZ under his name reportedly claimed he had studied English at a college in Vancouver, Stuff has reported.
Balraj says he was unaware that the document had been submitted and only discovered the issue after his employer informed him that his visa application had been declined.
INZ rejected his application after identifying what it described as a “fraudulent” certificate from the Canadian College of English Language. Balraj maintains that he had never seen the document. He is now unemployed and living in New Zealand unlawfully while appealing the immigration decision, as reported by Stuff.
The case is part of a wider group of complaints involving Indian migrant workers, most of whom are truck drivers seeking two-year extensions to their three-year Accredited Employer Work Visas.
According to Stuff, licensed immigration adviser Mehak Singh, from Tegh Law, is representing 20 affected clients. She alleges that false documents were submitted to INZ on their behalf without their knowledge. All 20 have had their visa applications declined, with some leaving New Zealand while others remain in the country unlawfully.
Lawyer Alistair McClymont is representing three additional clients, while immigration adviser Inderjit Matharu says she has five more clients facing similar circumstances.
Mehak has urged other potentially affected migrants to come forward, warning that the number of people involved could be significantly higher.
“In 12 years in the industry, I've never witnessed something of this scale,” Mehak said. “The blatant, brazen disregard for any law or any propriety or any professional conduct is just shocking,” as quoted by Stuff.
The allegations centre on documents relating to English-language requirements introduced under recent immigration instructions. Migrants applying for extensions must demonstrate their English proficiency.
Several applicants appear to have had their Pearson Test of English (PTE) scores altered. The required pass mark is 29, but one of Mehak's clients discovered that a score of 59 had been submitted to INZ without his knowledge, despite his actual result being 29, which would have met the requirement, Stuff has reported.
The client also alleged receiving emails that appeared to come from Pearson but were sent from addresses different from the company's usual email accounts.
Immigration professionals say the affected migrants are facing visa refusals despite claiming they were unaware of the false information. This is because immigration policy includes strict liability provisions concerning false or misleading information submitted with visa applications, potentially making applicants responsible even when they did not know about the documents, as reported by Stuff.
Mehak also alleged that several migrants never received letters of concern from INZ because their registered email addresses had been changed to accounts associated with an immigration agency in India. She said their phone numbers had also been altered, preventing immigration officials from contacting them directly.
She has filed Section 61 requests for most of her clients, asking INZ to reconsider their circumstances on special grounds. However, all the applications have been declined, leaving an appeal to the Associate Minister of Immigration as their remaining option, as reported by Stuff.
One affected migrant, Vikramjit Singh, said he had recently received his Section 61 application refusal. He had sent his wife back to India to protect her future prospects while he remained in New Zealand seeking justice.
“I’m still here trying to get justice. It has put a lot of financial pressure on me. I am relying on the kindness of family and friends to survive while this investigation is going on.
“I’m very angry. Through no fault of our own, she's gone ahead and played with our lives”, as quoted by Stuff.
Another affected migrant, identified by the name Maninder Singh*, alleged that many more families were facing similar difficulties.
“There are so many victims of this woman, so many families stranded here with unlawful status. And so many who haven’t come forward yet”, Stuff has quoted.
Matharu said her five clients had approached her after their visa applications were declined following consultations with Gill. Their Section 61 applications had also been unsuccessful.
“It’s very unfair because the clients are just not aware,” she said.
She alleged that one of her clients also had a falsified Canadian college document included in his immigration records without his knowledge.
“I asked him, ‘Have you ever been to Canada?’ and he said ‘No’,” she said, as quoted by Stuff.
Immigration New Zealand has launched an investigation into the allegations and has been interviewing some of the affected migrants at its Auckland offices this week. However, Gill claimed the department had not contacted her.
According to the affected workers, most were introduced to Gill through friends and colleagues. She reportedly operated from her home in Takanini, and several migrants claimed she had presented herself as a lawyer. Stuff also reported seeing an email in which she allegedly claimed to hold that title.
Gill is not a licensed immigration adviser. A licensed adviser with a similar name, Sukhpreet Kaur Gill, has clarified that she has no involvement in the matter.
Providing immigration advice or submitting applications on behalf of others without being a licensed adviser or lawyer can be illegal.
Mehak said an employee from Tegh Law contacted Gill on Tuesday while posing as a potential client. According to Mehak, Gill offered immigration assistance and quoted a minimum fee of $800. Stuff reported listening to a recording of the call and reviewing a translated transcript, although Gill denied the conversation took place.
Other migrants alleged that Gill charged them between $800 and $2,000 for her services, with some claiming she had also promised to provide English-language tuition.
In Balraj's case, he presented messages showing his repeated concerns about obtaining his visa extension before the deadline. He also provided records of a $1,600 payment to Gill, messages acknowledging the payment and a recorded telephone conversation following his visa refusal, as reported by Stuff.
Migrant advocate Sunny Sehgal, who is assisting Balraj, has sent Gill a demand for a refund and requested that INZ reconsider his case.
Sehgal said: “If he had seen these documents, he would have withdrawn his file or he would have taken the English exam.”
Gill denied ever meeting Balraj Singh or Vikramjit Singh. She also rejected claims that she had described herself as a lawyer, provided immigration advice or represented anyone before INZ.
“I deny all these things. I don’t know why they talk about me. They made a plan against me,” she said.
When presented with evidence of her alleged interactions with migrants and INZ, Gill responded: “You can alter chats, you can alter messages”, as quoted by Stuff.
She also denied speaking with the Tegh Law employee.
McClymont said the cases reflected a growing problem involving fraudulent or incompetent immigration advisers in New Zealand.
“It’s awful out there at the moment. It’s really bad.
“Ten years ago we would have maybe got two or three cases a year of people that had got themselves in a situation through either incompetent advice or fraudulent advice. Now we're basically getting one a week. It’s an epidemic”, as quoted by Stuff.
He said he believed INZ was placing the responsibility on a vulnerable group of migrants who may have been unaware of the alleged misconduct.
INZ declined to answer specific questions about Balraj's case, the decisions to refuse the affected migrants' applications or the timing of its investigation.
In a statement attributed to Jason Perry, INZ's National Manager of Investigations, the department said it was “limited in the information we can provide on active investigations, as doing so could compromise the integrity of the investigation and impact those involved”, as quoted by Stuff.
The department added, “Where false or misleading information is identified in a visa application, immigration officers consider the circumstances of the application and whether it is reasonable to decline the application before making a decision. An application is not automatically declined because false or misleading information has been identified. Where a temporary visa application has been declined, an applicant may in some circumstances ask Immigration New Zealand to reconsider the decision.”
Meanwhile, Bevan Yee, speaking on behalf of the Immigration Advisers Authority (IAA), said the organisation could not confirm whether it had received complaints about Gill, as doing so could “affect the integrity of any potential investigation”, as quoted by Stuff.
Yee said any information received would be assessed to determine whether it fell within the IAA's jurisdiction.
He added that “allegations concerning the creation or use of fraudulent visa or other documents may raise separate issues. This does not, by themselves, establish that immigration advice has been provided”.
The New Zealand Law Society said it could not comment on individual cases but clarified that its register identifies lawyers who hold current practising certificates. It also noted that it is illegal for unqualified individuals to claim they are lawyers.
The Canadian College of English Language did not respond to a request for comment before publication.
*(Name has been changed.)